DiagSplat · blind multiradius boundary critic

Full-30 · Round-1 vs Round-2 masks

The VLM selected the smallest adequate radius from 0, 16, 24, and 32 pixels using dirty observations, Round-1 renders, thin contours, native-resolution boundary crops, and residual as auxiliary evidence. No GT was used.

Selected +0px0
Selected +16px26
Selected +24px4
Selected +32px0

Frame 0001 selected +24 px

The two umbrella-like transients retain edge and learned-ghost contamination beyond +16; +24 is the smallest candidate with a stable safety band. Added mask area: 2.021%.

dirty observed
Round-1 render
Round-1 mask
Round-2 VLM-selected mask

Frame 0002 selected +16 px

The large defocused umbrella edge is covered by the current mask, but +16 is needed to give its soft perimeter a clear safety margin. Added mask area: 1.014%.

dirty observed
Round-1 render
Round-1 mask
Round-2 VLM-selected mask

Frame 0003 selected +16 px

The jacket, sleeves, hem, and mannequin neck are tightly traced; +16 supplies sufficient clearance without excessive background loss. Added mask area: 1.662%.

dirty observed
Round-1 render
Round-1 mask
Round-2 VLM-selected mask

Frame 0004 selected +16 px

The cabinet outer frame, protruding side rail, and feet sit close to the current contour; +16 clears all rigid edges. Added mask area: 1.405%.

dirty observed
Round-1 render
Round-1 mask
Round-2 VLM-selected mask

Frame 0005 selected +16 px

The sign cloth and lower support are tightly bounded; +16 is sufficient around the full rectangular transient. Added mask area: 0.687%.

dirty observed
Round-1 render
Round-1 mask
Round-2 VLM-selected mask

Frame 0006 selected +16 px

The folding screen contour touches the black top frame and outer uprights; +16 provides the needed perimeter margin. Added mask area: 2.374%.

dirty observed
Round-1 render
Round-1 mask
Round-2 VLM-selected mask

Frame 0007 selected +16 px

The parasol rim and exposed tips are close to the current boundary; +16 safely encloses them. Added mask area: 0.747%.

dirty observed
Round-1 render
Round-1 mask
Round-2 VLM-selected mask

Frame 0008 selected +16 px

The mirror frame and bottom support are tightly traced; +16 covers their thin rigid edges. Added mask area: 1.637%.

dirty observed
Round-1 render
Round-1 mask
Round-2 VLM-selected mask

Frame 0009 selected +16 px

The hanging scroll, rod, side trim, and lower edge require a small but explicit safety band; +16 is adequate. Added mask area: 2.038%.

dirty observed
Round-1 render
Round-1 mask
Round-2 VLM-selected mask

Frame 0010 selected +16 px

Several cushion components touch or nearly touch their component contours; +16 clears all of them. Added mask area: 2.339%.

dirty observed
Round-1 render
Round-1 mask
Round-2 VLM-selected mask

Frame 0011 selected +16 px

The cabinet top rail, side posts, and feet are close to the current mask; +16 supplies sufficient clearance. Added mask area: 1.385%.

dirty observed
Round-1 render
Round-1 mask
Round-2 VLM-selected mask

Frame 0012 selected +24 px

The transient is a broad soft motion-blur envelope; +16 remains too close to faint contamination at several diagonal edges, while +24 is safely outside it. Added mask area: 3.322%.

dirty observed
Round-1 render
Round-1 mask
Round-2 VLM-selected mask

Frame 0013 selected +16 px

The red cloth has crisp but tightly traced side, top, and bottom edges; +16 is the smallest adequate expansion. Added mask area: 1.829%.

dirty observed
Round-1 render
Round-1 mask
Round-2 VLM-selected mask

Frame 0014 selected +16 px

The parasol rim and small protruding tips need a modest safety band; +16 is sufficient. Added mask area: 0.744%.

dirty observed
Round-1 render
Round-1 mask
Round-2 VLM-selected mask

Frame 0015 selected +16 px

The chair, runner, legs, and lower fabric are tightly enclosed; +16 clears the compound silhouette. Added mask area: 1.035%.

dirty observed
Round-1 render
Round-1 mask
Round-2 VLM-selected mask

Frame 0016 selected +16 px

The foreground panel is mildly defocused but its contamination is contained once the boundary is expanded by +16. Added mask area: 1.086%.

dirty observed
Round-1 render
Round-1 mask
Round-2 VLM-selected mask

Frame 0017 selected +16 px

The mirror frame, reflected content boundary, and tripod/support are tightly traced; +16 is adequate. Added mask area: 1.599%.

dirty observed
Round-1 render
Round-1 mask
Round-2 VLM-selected mask

Frame 0018 selected +16 px

The thin white frame and lower support require clearance on both sides; +16 provides it without unnecessary expansion. Added mask area: 1.641%.

dirty observed
Round-1 render
Round-1 mask
Round-2 VLM-selected mask

Frame 0019 selected +16 px

The vase, flower stems, basket, and sign form several fine components; +16 gives each a consistent safety margin. Added mask area: 2.060%.

dirty observed
Round-1 render
Round-1 mask
Round-2 VLM-selected mask

Frame 0020 selected +16 px

The person, hair, hands, mirror, and stand are all close to the current contour; +16 covers the compound boundary. Added mask area: 1.773%.

dirty observed
Round-1 render
Round-1 mask
Round-2 VLM-selected mask

Frame 0021 selected +16 px

The scroll body, top mount, and bottom roller are tightly bounded; +16 is sufficient. Added mask area: 2.150%.

dirty observed
Round-1 render
Round-1 mask
Round-2 VLM-selected mask

Frame 0022 selected +16 px

The cabinet top bar, side posts, lower rail, and feet need a small perimeter expansion; +16 clears them. Added mask area: 1.004%.

dirty observed
Round-1 render
Round-1 mask
Round-2 VLM-selected mask

Frame 0023 selected +16 px

The jacket, parasol tips, stand shaft, and base are tightly traced; +16 encloses all fine structures. Added mask area: 1.832%.

dirty observed
Round-1 render
Round-1 mask
Round-2 VLM-selected mask

Frame 0024 selected +24 px

The dark foreground object has a wide motion-blurred boundary; +24 is the smallest candidate that leaves a convincing clean margin along the diagonal edge. Added mask area: 1.966%.

dirty observed
Round-1 render
Round-1 mask
Round-2 VLM-selected mask

Frame 0025 selected +16 px

Both mirror assemblies have thin frames, supports, wheels, and reflected boundaries; +16 provides adequate clearance. Added mask area: 3.041%.

dirty observed
Round-1 render
Round-1 mask
Round-2 VLM-selected mask

Frame 0026 selected +16 px

The person's sleeve, hand, shoulder, and torso are tightly bounded but visually crisp enough that +16 is sufficient. Added mask area: 1.348%.

dirty observed
Round-1 render
Round-1 mask
Round-2 VLM-selected mask

Frame 0027 selected +16 px

The parasol perimeter and handle are close to the current mask; +16 gives a complete safety band. Added mask area: 0.800%.

dirty observed
Round-1 render
Round-1 mask
Round-2 VLM-selected mask

Frame 0028 selected +16 px

The cabinet's long top rail, side edges, and feet are tightly traced; +16 safely clears them. Added mask area: 1.649%.

dirty observed
Round-1 render
Round-1 mask
Round-2 VLM-selected mask

Frame 0029 selected +16 px

The mirror, rear leg, lower wheels, and long frame edges require a modest expansion; +16 is adequate. Added mask area: 2.348%.

dirty observed
Round-1 render
Round-1 mask
Round-2 VLM-selected mask

Frame 0030 selected +24 px

The foreground flowers and stems are strongly defocused with soft, irregular edges; +24 is needed for a stable contamination margin. Added mask area: 3.544%.

dirty observed
Round-1 render
Round-1 mask
Round-2 VLM-selected mask