{
  "definition": {
    "tiny_threshold": 5.165285381281137e-07,
    "tiny_threshold_source": "1st percentile of final geometric-mean scale in clean x0 Vanilla 3DGS",
    "needle_threshold": 10.0,
    "edge_region": "top 20% held-out GT luminance-gradient pixels"
  },
  "runs": {
    "adaptive_blend": {
      "0": {
        "PSNR": 27.258615493774414,
        "SSIM": 0.8918974995613098,
        "LPIPS": 0.23866799473762512,
        "edge_PSNR": 21.11329002166152,
        "flat_PSNR": 32.891528545748926,
        "gaussian_count": 188761,
        "scale_geometric_q01": 3.785119076837873e-07,
        "scale_geometric_q10": 8.758715557632968e-05,
        "scale_geometric_q50": 0.003365578129887581,
        "tiny_fraction_vs_clean_reference": 0.011729117773268842,
        "needle_fraction_aspect_gt_10": 0.9478864807878746,
        "extreme_needle_fraction_aspect_gt_20": 0.9082702465021906,
        "tiny_needle_fraction": 0.011729117773268842,
        "low_opacity_fraction_lt_005": 0.477460916185017,
        "opacity_weighted_count": 46369.14422321574,
        "proxy_warning": "Tiny/needle statistics are mechanism proxies, not ground-truth labels of erroneous Gaussians."
      },
      "16": {
        "PSNR": 27.57955551147461,
        "SSIM": 0.9010432362556458,
        "LPIPS": 0.1894153356552124,
        "edge_PSNR": 21.380446377513216,
        "flat_PSNR": 33.62784568736856,
        "gaussian_count": 181323,
        "scale_geometric_q01": 2.4224917297033246e-06,
        "scale_geometric_q10": 0.00015046685875859113,
        "scale_geometric_q50": 0.0038088010624051094,
        "tiny_fraction_vs_clean_reference": 0.0042575955615117775,
        "needle_fraction_aspect_gt_10": 0.9537014057786382,
        "extreme_needle_fraction_aspect_gt_20": 0.9169934316109926,
        "tiny_needle_fraction": 0.0042575955615117775,
        "low_opacity_fraction_lt_005": 0.48320952113079974,
        "opacity_weighted_count": 40970.71798012755,
        "proxy_warning": "Tiny/needle statistics are mechanism proxies, not ground-truth labels of erroneous Gaussians."
      },
      "4": {
        "PSNR": 25.051036834716797,
        "SSIM": 0.8885499238967896,
        "LPIPS": 0.22445189952850342,
        "edge_PSNR": 18.97374820873677,
        "flat_PSNR": 30.964240808541966,
        "gaussian_count": 113895,
        "scale_geometric_q01": 1.462847023503855e-05,
        "scale_geometric_q10": 0.00039807023713365206,
        "scale_geometric_q50": 0.009311934933066368,
        "tiny_fraction_vs_clean_reference": 0.0015452829360375784,
        "needle_fraction_aspect_gt_10": 0.9098643487422626,
        "extreme_needle_fraction_aspect_gt_20": 0.8495280741033407,
        "tiny_needle_fraction": 0.0015452829360375784,
        "low_opacity_fraction_lt_005": 0.4281399534659116,
        "opacity_weighted_count": 29942.41326304247,
        "proxy_warning": "Tiny/needle statistics are mechanism proxies, not ground-truth labels of erroneous Gaussians."
      },
      "64": {
        "PSNR": 28.071706771850586,
        "SSIM": 0.8699930906295776,
        "LPIPS": 0.18763911724090576,
        "edge_PSNR": 21.98116767660116,
        "flat_PSNR": 33.684993569977095,
        "gaussian_count": 198000,
        "scale_geometric_q01": 1.785553287845687e-05,
        "scale_geometric_q10": 0.0003409275872400031,
        "scale_geometric_q50": 0.005600667325779796,
        "tiny_fraction_vs_clean_reference": 0.001186868686868687,
        "needle_fraction_aspect_gt_10": 0.9360858585858586,
        "extreme_needle_fraction_aspect_gt_20": 0.8879040404040404,
        "tiny_needle_fraction": 0.001186868686868687,
        "low_opacity_fraction_lt_005": 0.4064949494949495,
        "opacity_weighted_count": 47105.0894702936,
        "proxy_warning": "Tiny/needle statistics are mechanism proxies, not ground-truth labels of erroneous Gaussians."
      }
    },
    "additive_anchor": {
      "0": {
        "PSNR": 27.64495849609375,
        "SSIM": 0.8949079513549805,
        "LPIPS": 0.2368522435426712,
        "edge_PSNR": 21.396293149624054,
        "flat_PSNR": 33.741730013273255,
        "gaussian_count": 208950,
        "scale_geometric_q01": 1.776224442551211e-07,
        "scale_geometric_q10": 0.0001079150322766509,
        "scale_geometric_q50": 0.003002543468028307,
        "tiny_fraction_vs_clean_reference": 0.013821488394352715,
        "needle_fraction_aspect_gt_10": 0.9527111749222302,
        "extreme_needle_fraction_aspect_gt_20": 0.9177698013878919,
        "tiny_needle_fraction": 0.013821488394352715,
        "low_opacity_fraction_lt_005": 0.4699736779133764,
        "opacity_weighted_count": 50671.43625942914,
        "proxy_warning": "Tiny/needle statistics are mechanism proxies, not ground-truth labels of erroneous Gaussians."
      },
      "64": {
        "PSNR": 26.856220245361328,
        "SSIM": 0.8464237451553345,
        "LPIPS": 0.2512722909450531,
        "edge_PSNR": 20.808007370293442,
        "flat_PSNR": 32.53710877992532,
        "gaussian_count": 166611,
        "scale_geometric_q01": 4.9548771130503155e-06,
        "scale_geometric_q10": 0.00018603337230160832,
        "scale_geometric_q50": 0.003695585997775197,
        "tiny_fraction_vs_clean_reference": 0.002502835947206367,
        "needle_fraction_aspect_gt_10": 0.9500753251586029,
        "extreme_needle_fraction_aspect_gt_20": 0.9105821344329006,
        "tiny_needle_fraction": 0.002502835947206367,
        "low_opacity_fraction_lt_005": 0.48451782895487094,
        "opacity_weighted_count": 37962.24353942077,
        "proxy_warning": "Tiny/needle statistics are mechanism proxies, not ground-truth labels of erroneous Gaussians."
      }
    },
    "confidence_linear": {
      "0": {
        "PSNR": 27.880367279052734,
        "SSIM": 0.8982327580451965,
        "LPIPS": 0.232533261179924,
        "edge_PSNR": 21.666086319138937,
        "flat_PSNR": 33.740577193193396,
        "gaussian_count": 208069,
        "scale_geometric_q01": 3.8283143226180973e-07,
        "scale_geometric_q10": 0.00013967549311928452,
        "scale_geometric_q50": 0.0031332869548350573,
        "tiny_fraction_vs_clean_reference": 0.010770465566711043,
        "needle_fraction_aspect_gt_10": 0.9539479691832997,
        "extreme_needle_fraction_aspect_gt_20": 0.9198390918397262,
        "tiny_needle_fraction": 0.010770465566711043,
        "low_opacity_fraction_lt_005": 0.461568037526013,
        "opacity_weighted_count": 51223.36160160968,
        "proxy_warning": "Tiny/needle statistics are mechanism proxies, not ground-truth labels of erroneous Gaussians."
      },
      "16": {
        "PSNR": 28.25263023376465,
        "SSIM": 0.8887767791748047,
        "LPIPS": 0.23539209365844727,
        "edge_PSNR": 22.14707074378698,
        "flat_PSNR": 33.57677076619173,
        "gaussian_count": 207307,
        "scale_geometric_q01": 3.024720615485421e-07,
        "scale_geometric_q10": 0.00015517607680521907,
        "scale_geometric_q50": 0.0035518507938832045,
        "tiny_fraction_vs_clean_reference": 0.011943639143878403,
        "needle_fraction_aspect_gt_10": 0.9523653325743945,
        "extreme_needle_fraction_aspect_gt_20": 0.9165247676151794,
        "tiny_needle_fraction": 0.011943639143878403,
        "low_opacity_fraction_lt_005": 0.45960339014119156,
        "opacity_weighted_count": 50228.71064954257,
        "proxy_warning": "Tiny/needle statistics are mechanism proxies, not ground-truth labels of erroneous Gaussians."
      },
      "4": {
        "PSNR": 27.320592880249023,
        "SSIM": 0.8919014930725098,
        "LPIPS": 0.23954765498638153,
        "edge_PSNR": 21.24569650641881,
        "flat_PSNR": 32.90772503463641,
        "gaussian_count": 219508,
        "scale_geometric_q01": 9.092182402525854e-09,
        "scale_geometric_q10": 5.969260564597789e-05,
        "scale_geometric_q50": 0.002570663928054273,
        "tiny_fraction_vs_clean_reference": 0.03199883375548955,
        "needle_fraction_aspect_gt_10": 0.957391074584981,
        "extreme_needle_fraction_aspect_gt_20": 0.9246132259416513,
        "tiny_needle_fraction": 0.03199883375548955,
        "low_opacity_fraction_lt_005": 0.44017985677059607,
        "opacity_weighted_count": 56082.562191843565,
        "proxy_warning": "Tiny/needle statistics are mechanism proxies, not ground-truth labels of erroneous Gaussians."
      },
      "64": {
        "PSNR": 27.3310546875,
        "SSIM": 0.8445523381233215,
        "LPIPS": 0.24558517336845398,
        "edge_PSNR": 21.146081672412535,
        "flat_PSNR": 33.20702801517863,
        "gaussian_count": 239418,
        "scale_geometric_q01": 2.2809634813825147e-07,
        "scale_geometric_q10": 0.00010755480398074725,
        "scale_geometric_q50": 0.002725399797782302,
        "tiny_fraction_vs_clean_reference": 0.013344861288624915,
        "needle_fraction_aspect_gt_10": 0.953650101496128,
        "extreme_needle_fraction_aspect_gt_20": 0.917324511941458,
        "tiny_needle_fraction": 0.013344861288624915,
        "low_opacity_fraction_lt_005": 0.4710339239322023,
        "opacity_weighted_count": 56595.31681138382,
        "proxy_warning": "Tiny/needle statistics are mechanism proxies, not ground-truth labels of erroneous Gaussians."
      }
    },
    "curriculum": {
      "0": {
        "PSNR": 27.492883682250977,
        "SSIM": 0.8955017328262329,
        "LPIPS": 0.23276419937610626,
        "edge_PSNR": 21.357447238304484,
        "flat_PSNR": 33.1555148917027,
        "gaussian_count": 206741,
        "scale_geometric_q01": 2.9241411539260304e-06,
        "scale_geometric_q10": 0.00016748385678511113,
        "scale_geometric_q50": 0.00340370018966496,
        "tiny_fraction_vs_clean_reference": 0.005402895410199234,
        "needle_fraction_aspect_gt_10": 0.9518769861807769,
        "extreme_needle_fraction_aspect_gt_20": 0.9148112856182373,
        "tiny_needle_fraction": 0.005402895410199234,
        "low_opacity_fraction_lt_005": 0.4659114544284878,
        "opacity_weighted_count": 50780.64295602597,
        "proxy_warning": "Tiny/needle statistics are mechanism proxies, not ground-truth labels of erroneous Gaussians."
      },
      "64": {
        "PSNR": 26.560436248779297,
        "SSIM": 0.8598828315734863,
        "LPIPS": 0.18492969870567322,
        "edge_PSNR": 20.568679621626043,
        "flat_PSNR": 31.872764336980577,
        "gaussian_count": 282791,
        "scale_geometric_q01": 6.053306879039156e-06,
        "scale_geometric_q10": 0.0002095832023769617,
        "scale_geometric_q50": 0.0037718620151281357,
        "tiny_fraction_vs_clean_reference": 0.0016231068174022512,
        "needle_fraction_aspect_gt_10": 0.9449664239668165,
        "extreme_needle_fraction_aspect_gt_20": 0.9044382600577812,
        "tiny_needle_fraction": 0.0016231068174022512,
        "low_opacity_fraction_lt_005": 0.4526240226881336,
        "opacity_weighted_count": 58198.503212608564,
        "proxy_warning": "Tiny/needle statistics are mechanism proxies, not ground-truth labels of erroneous Gaussians."
      }
    },
    "frequency_split": {
      "0": {
        "PSNR": 27.57876968383789,
        "SSIM": 0.8938112258911133,
        "LPIPS": 0.2361672818660736,
        "edge_PSNR": 21.362243336270694,
        "flat_PSNR": 33.56804986515882,
        "gaussian_count": 187429,
        "scale_geometric_q01": 1.4713787595610483e-06,
        "scale_geometric_q10": 0.00015194323204923422,
        "scale_geometric_q50": 0.0035935842897742987,
        "tiny_fraction_vs_clean_reference": 0.006253034482390665,
        "needle_fraction_aspect_gt_10": 0.9460542392052457,
        "extreme_needle_fraction_aspect_gt_20": 0.9061297878129851,
        "tiny_needle_fraction": 0.006253034482390665,
        "low_opacity_fraction_lt_005": 0.43940905622929216,
        "opacity_weighted_count": 49337.01571008105,
        "proxy_warning": "Tiny/needle statistics are mechanism proxies, not ground-truth labels of erroneous Gaussians."
      },
      "64": {
        "PSNR": 27.393856048583984,
        "SSIM": 0.8306059837341309,
        "LPIPS": 0.22460408508777618,
        "edge_PSNR": 21.497378389881405,
        "flat_PSNR": 32.007681082404346,
        "gaussian_count": 559960,
        "scale_geometric_q01": 9.666635113897426e-12,
        "scale_geometric_q10": 1.3971730550110807e-05,
        "scale_geometric_q50": 0.0016639146488159895,
        "tiny_fraction_vs_clean_reference": 0.044447817701264374,
        "needle_fraction_aspect_gt_10": 0.9483177369812129,
        "extreme_needle_fraction_aspect_gt_20": 0.9095703264518894,
        "tiny_needle_fraction": 0.044447817701264374,
        "low_opacity_fraction_lt_005": 0.5594238874205301,
        "opacity_weighted_count": 103844.7671958461,
        "proxy_warning": "Tiny/needle statistics are mechanism proxies, not ground-truth labels of erroneous Gaussians."
      }
    },
    "variance_deadzone": {
      "0": {
        "PSNR": 27.28668212890625,
        "SSIM": 0.8926030993461609,
        "LPIPS": 0.24144701659679413,
        "edge_PSNR": 21.119789892023736,
        "flat_PSNR": 33.219915651093686,
        "gaussian_count": 173073,
        "scale_geometric_q01": 2.2605937203934447e-07,
        "scale_geometric_q10": 0.00010663342545740307,
        "scale_geometric_q50": 0.0032632192596793175,
        "tiny_fraction_vs_clean_reference": 0.013514528551536058,
        "needle_fraction_aspect_gt_10": 0.9490850681504336,
        "extreme_needle_fraction_aspect_gt_20": 0.9102748551189382,
        "tiny_needle_fraction": 0.013514528551536058,
        "low_opacity_fraction_lt_005": 0.4538200643659034,
        "opacity_weighted_count": 45095.29228609871,
        "proxy_warning": "Tiny/needle statistics are mechanism proxies, not ground-truth labels of erroneous Gaussians."
      },
      "64": {
        "PSNR": 27.158855438232422,
        "SSIM": 0.8385095596313477,
        "LPIPS": 0.25623634457588196,
        "edge_PSNR": 21.25842378023847,
        "flat_PSNR": 32.300201334643745,
        "gaussian_count": 123030,
        "scale_geometric_q01": 2.095348411330633e-06,
        "scale_geometric_q10": 0.00019718282565008854,
        "scale_geometric_q50": 0.00428260094486177,
        "tiny_fraction_vs_clean_reference": 0.006697553442249858,
        "needle_fraction_aspect_gt_10": 0.9481833699097781,
        "extreme_needle_fraction_aspect_gt_20": 0.906234251808502,
        "tiny_needle_fraction": 0.006697553442249858,
        "low_opacity_fraction_lt_005": 0.45133707225879865,
        "opacity_weighted_count": 32437.148607541774,
        "proxy_warning": "Tiny/needle statistics are mechanism proxies, not ground-truth labels of erroneous Gaussians."
      }
    }
  }
}