Auto-ID: Merging atoms with bits around the globe

Steve Hodges (seh1000)

2003-06-09

University of Cambridge
Department of Engineering
Laboratory for Communication Engineering

My knowledge of the general subject area
Novice )-:**
 |-:**
 |-:*******
 |-:****
Expert (-:**
 
My knowledge of this specific topic
Novice )-:**
 |-:**
 |-:**********
 |-:**
Expert (-:*
 
Content of talk
Boring )-:
 |-:*
 |-:
 |-:*****
Interesting (-:***********
 
Presentation
Dull )-:
 |-:*
 |-:*
 |-:******
Lively (-:*********
 
Presentation
Obscure )-:
 |-:
 |-:**
 |-:*****
Illuminating (-:**********
 
Presentation
Trivializing )-:*
 |-:*
 |-:**
 |-:*****
Insightful (-:********
 
Presentation
Hesitant )-:
 |-:
 |-:*
 |-:****
Confident (-:************
 
Slides
Poor )-:
 |-:
 |-:*
 |-:******
Good (-:**********
 
Slides
Too empty )-:
 |-:*
Just right (-:****************
 |-:
Too crowded )-:
 
Slides
Too few pics )-:*
 |-:**
Just right (-:*************
 |-:*
Too many pics )-:
 
Slides
Too few slides )-:
 |-:
Just right (-:*************
 |-:****
Too many slides )-:
 
Research aspect
Seen it all before )-:
 |-:**
 |-:*
 |-:**********
Very original (-:****
 
Research aspect
It'll never work )-:
 |-:
 |-:**
 |-:*******
Very promising (-:********
 
Overall quality of presentation
I hated it )-:
 |-:
 |-:**
 |-:*****
I loved it (-:**********
 

Positive comments:

Excellent presentation. Thank you.

Nice talk. Good speaker.

Negative comments:

Could have tailored more to this audience. Shame to miss out on the technical part at the end, potentially the most interesting.

Discussion of user privacy would be interesting - users could have their identity tracked by scanning and logging the set of items each person carries.

Too many details. Presentation could be shorter.

Introduction about autoID centre too long :-( . Video too long. Comparison of auto-ID with the invention of computers and the internet is ridiculous!

Valid HTML 4.0! Python Generated by fff2html, © 2003 Frank Stajano