{
  "source_pdf": "2025-fairground.pdf",
  "mode": "hybrid",
  "model": "hybrid: Nemotron 3.5 Parse layout + vision-LLM transcription",
  "parser_identity": {
    "model": "nvidia/Nemotron-3.5-Parse",
    "revision": "62cb1e4ba153d113ff64aaf2be6e068c377cf53c",
    "backend": "vllm",
    "coordinates": "content_normalized",
    "prompt": "</s><s><predict_bbox><predict_classes><output_no_text><predict_no_text_in_pic>",
    "layout_max_tokens": 3000,
    "reading_order": "whitespace-cuts-v1-full-only",
    "layout_mode": "guarded",
    "guard": {
      "coverage": 0.95,
      "min_chars": 20,
      "min_gain": 0.005,
      "duplicate_tolerance": 0.001
    },
    "box_snap": "text-lines-v1",
    "box_snap_params": {
      "line_tolerance": 0.003,
      "gap_factor": 2.5,
      "min_gap": 0.006,
      "max_extension": 0.15,
      "min_line_glyphs": 3,
      "min_gain": 3
    },
    "retry_prompt": "</s><s><predict_bbox><predict_classes><output_markdown><predict_text_in_pic>",
    "retry_max_tokens": 8744
  },
  "prompt": "</s><s><predict_bbox><predict_classes><output_no_text><predict_no_text_in_pic>",
  "num_pages": 6,
  "page_sizes": [
    {
      "width_pt": 612.0,
      "height_pt": 792.0,
      "width_px": 1583,
      "height_px": 2048
    },
    {
      "width_pt": 612.0,
      "height_pt": 792.0,
      "width_px": 1583,
      "height_px": 2048
    },
    {
      "width_pt": 612.0,
      "height_pt": 792.0,
      "width_px": 1583,
      "height_px": 2048
    },
    {
      "width_pt": 612.0,
      "height_pt": 792.0,
      "width_px": 1583,
      "height_px": 2048
    },
    {
      "width_pt": 612.0,
      "height_pt": 792.0,
      "width_px": 1583,
      "height_px": 2048
    },
    {
      "width_pt": 612.0,
      "height_pt": 792.0,
      "width_px": 1583,
      "height_px": 2048
    }
  ],
  "pages": [
    [
      {
        "page": 1,
        "order": 0,
        "class": "Picture",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.002,
          0.0906,
          0.042,
          0.1227
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          3.2,
          185.5,
          66.5,
          251.3
        ],
        "text": "",
        "image_file": "page001_el00_Picture.png",
        "figure_type": "diagram",
        "figure_description": "A small square icon/button containing a circular logo (a blue-and-yellow ring enclosing a red bookmark/flag shape) above the two-line text 'Check for updates'. It appears to be a user-interface element rather than a data plot.",
        "figure_data_extractable": false,
        "figure_data_vlm": {
          "nodes": [
            {
              "label": "Check for updates"
            }
          ],
          "edges": [],
          "precision": "exact"
        }
      },
      {
        "page": 1,
        "order": 1,
        "class": "Title",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.123,
          0.0914,
          0.873,
          0.1156
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          194.7,
          187.2,
          1382.0,
          236.7
        ],
        "text": "**A FAIR Case for a Live Computational Commons**"
      },
      {
        "page": 1,
        "order": 2,
        "class": "Caption",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.1533,
          0.1313,
          0.3076,
          0.1891
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          242.7,
          268.9,
          486.9,
          387.3
        ],
        "text": "Cyrus Omar\nUniversity of Michigan\nMichigan, USA\ncomar@umich.edu"
      },
      {
        "page": 1,
        "order": 3,
        "class": "Caption",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.377,
          0.1305,
          0.6221,
          0.1898
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          596.8,
          267.3,
          984.8,
          388.7
        ],
        "text": "Michael Coblenz\nUniversity of California at San Diego\nSan Diego, USA\nmcoblenz@ucsd.edu"
      },
      {
        "page": 1,
        "order": 4,
        "class": "Caption",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.6709,
          0.1305,
          0.8623,
          0.1883
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          1062.0,
          267.3,
          1365.0,
          385.6
        ],
        "text": "Anil Madhavapeddy\nUniversity of Cambridge\nCambridge, United Kingdom\navsm2@cam.ac.uk"
      },
      {
        "page": 1,
        "order": 5,
        "class": "Section-header",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0879,
          0.2016,
          0.1621,
          0.2125
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          139.1,
          412.9,
          256.6,
          435.2
        ],
        "text": "Abstract"
      },
      {
        "page": 1,
        "order": 6,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0869,
          0.2219,
          0.4824,
          0.2789
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          137.6,
          454.5,
          763.6,
          571.2
        ],
        "text": "Scientists increasingly write software as part of large-scale collaborative workflows, but current tools make it difficult to follow FAIR principles (findability, accessibility, interop- erability, reusability) and ensure reproducibility by default."
      },
      {
        "page": 1,
        "order": 7,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0869,
          0.2828,
          0.4814,
          0.3992
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          137.6,
          579.2,
          762.1,
          817.6
        ],
        "text": "This paper proposes Fairground, a computational com-mons designed as a collaborative notebook system where thousands of scientific artifacts are authored, collected, and maintained together in executable form in a manner that is FAIR, reproducible, and live by default. Unlike existing platforms, Fairground notebooks can reference each other as libraries, forming a single planetary-scale live program executed by a distributed scheduler."
      },
      {
        "page": 1,
        "order": 8,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0869,
          0.4031,
          0.4834,
          0.5055
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          137.6,
          825.5,
          765.2,
          1035.3
        ],
        "text": "We describe the design of Fair Python, a purely functional subset of Python, and a foreign function interface for in- teroperating with existing code. Through three interleaved research tracks focusing on language design, interoperability, and distributed execution, we aim to create a next-generation collaborative scientific workflow system that makes best practices the path of least resistance."
      },
      {
        "page": 1,
        "order": 9,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0889,
          0.5203,
          0.4844,
          0.593
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          140.7,
          1065.6,
          766.8,
          1214.5
        ],
        "text": "**CCS Concepts:** • Human-centered computing → Scientific visualization; Collaborative interaction; _Open source software_; • Software and its engineering → Collaboration in software development; Interoperability; _Functional languages_."
      },
      {
        "page": 1,
        "order": 10,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0879,
          0.6078,
          0.4824,
          0.6344
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          139.1,
          1244.8,
          763.6,
          1299.3
        ],
        "text": "*Keywords*: python, reproducible, scientific computing, functional, visualization, fair, reusability"
      },
      {
        "page": 1,
        "order": 11,
        "class": "Section-header",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0869,
          0.6516,
          0.2471,
          0.6602
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          137.6,
          1334.5,
          391.2,
          1352.1
        ],
        "text": "**ACM Reference Format:**"
      },
      {
        "page": 1,
        "order": 12,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0869,
          0.6648,
          0.4805,
          0.743
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          137.6,
          1361.5,
          760.6,
          1521.7
        ],
        "text": "Cyrus Omar, Michael Coblenz, and Anil Madhavapeddy. 2025. A FAIR Case for a Live Computational Commons. In _Proceedings of the 2nd ACM SIGPLAN International Workshop on Programming for the Planet_ (PROPL '25), October 12–18, 2025, Singapore, Singapore. ACM, New York, NY, USA, 6 pages. https://doi.org/10.1145/3759536.3763802"
      },
      {
        "page": 1,
        "order": 13,
        "class": "Section-header",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5195,
          0.2016,
          0.6611,
          0.2133
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          822.4,
          412.9,
          1046.5,
          436.8
        ],
        "text": "**1 Introduction**"
      },
      {
        "page": 1,
        "order": 14,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5186,
          0.2211,
          0.9131,
          0.3547
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          820.9,
          452.8,
          1445.4,
          726.4
        ],
        "text": "Scientists increasingly write software as contributors to large-scale collaborative workflows. For example, data scientists write software to standardize and analyze data [17, 33, 41, 44] collected by field and experimental scientists. These analyses flow into software written by computational scientists to model natural phenomena, e.g. fish population dynamics [20, 50]. These models may then flow into integrative models, like those developed to predict the impact of ecological interventions and climate policies [13, 15]."
      },
      {
        "page": 1,
        "order": 15,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5176,
          0.3578,
          0.9111,
          0.3844
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          819.4,
          732.8,
          1442.3,
          787.3
        ],
        "text": "Scientists engage in these collaborative computational\nworkflows using a patchwork of:"
      },
      {
        "page": 1,
        "order": 16,
        "class": "List-item",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5449,
          0.3914,
          0.9121,
          0.4484
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          862.6,
          801.6,
          1443.9,
          918.3
        ],
        "text": "• programming environments (e.g. spreadsheets, computational notebooks like Jupyter, and IDEs) for various programming languages (e.g. Python, R, Scala, Bash, C++, and Fortran) and libraries (e.g. pandas, tidyverse),"
      },
      {
        "page": 1,
        "order": 17,
        "class": "List-item",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5459,
          0.4516,
          0.9141,
          0.4789
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          864.2,
          924.9,
          1447.0,
          980.8
        ],
        "text": "• code and data management systems (e.g. shared stor-\nage, databases, version control systems),"
      },
      {
        "page": 1,
        "order": 18,
        "class": "List-item",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5459,
          0.482,
          0.9102,
          0.5242
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          864.2,
          987.1,
          1440.8,
          1073.6
        ],
        "text": "- hardware and cloud management systems (e.g. cluster job systems, cloud environments like AWS and Google Earth Engine),"
      },
      {
        "page": 1,
        "order": 19,
        "class": "List-item",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5459,
          0.5273,
          0.7812,
          0.5398
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          864.2,
          1079.9,
          1236.6,
          1105.5
        ],
        "text": "• authoring tools (e.g. LATEX, Word),"
      },
      {
        "page": 1,
        "order": 20,
        "class": "List-item",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5459,
          0.543,
          0.8203,
          0.5547
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          864.2,
          1112.1,
          1298.5,
          1136.0
        ],
        "text": "- communication tools (e.g. email, Slack),"
      },
      {
        "page": 1,
        "order": 21,
        "class": "List-item",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5459,
          0.5578,
          0.9121,
          0.5844
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          864.2,
          1142.4,
          1443.9,
          1196.9
        ],
        "text": "- domain-specific graphical applications (e.g. GIS tools, illustration tools, and custom applications)."
      },
      {
        "page": 1,
        "order": 22,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5186,
          0.5914,
          0.915,
          0.7094
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          820.9,
          1211.2,
          1448.4,
          1452.9
        ],
        "text": "When using these tools, scientists must put in consid-erable extra effort to follow identified best practices for data and software in the context of large-scale collabora-tive workflows, including the **FAIR criteria** for data and software [6, 53] (**findability**, **accessibility**, **interoperabil-ity**, **reusability**) and **reproducibility**. By default, artifacts are not FAIR (causing scientists to waste time reinventing the wheel) and not reproducible [23, 32, 46]."
      },
      {
        "page": 1,
        "order": 23,
        "class": "Section-header",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5205,
          0.7242,
          0.8877,
          0.7367
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          824.0,
          1483.2,
          1405.2,
          1508.8
        ],
        "text": "**1.1 The importance of reproducible open science**"
      },
      {
        "page": 1,
        "order": 24,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5186,
          0.7438,
          0.9141,
          0.9062
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          820.9,
          1523.3,
          1447.0,
          1855.9
        ],
        "text": "Reproducibility is a keystone of scientific discovery but un-\nfortunately, many scientific disciplines are undergoing a\nreplication crisis, including psychology [51], economics [7],\nand extending to the physical sciences: 70% of researchers re-\nported that they failed to reproduce others' experiments [4].\nIn systems biology, 49% of published models were not re-\nproducible [48]. A 2023 workshop at the National Center\nfor Atmospheric Research explored the challenges of repro-\nducibility in science that relies on computation, with presen-\nters arguing that new techniques are needed to ensure that\nsoftware-dependent results can be reproduced [32]."
      },
      {
        "page": 1,
        "order": 25,
        "class": "Picture",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0879,
          0.8031,
          0.167,
          0.825
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          139.1,
          1644.7,
          264.4,
          1689.6
        ],
        "text": "",
        "image_file": "page001_el25_Picture.png",
        "figure_type": "other",
        "figure_description": "A Creative Commons license badge on a gray background, showing a circular 'CC' icon on the left and a circular person (attribution) icon on the right, with the text 'BY' beneath the person icon. It is a logo/badge indicating a CC BY license, not a data visualization.",
        "figure_data_extractable": false
      },
      {
        "page": 1,
        "order": 26,
        "class": "Footnote",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0879,
          0.8305,
          0.4795,
          0.8508
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          139.1,
          1700.9,
          759.0,
          1742.4
        ],
        "text": "This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License."
      },
      {
        "page": 1,
        "order": 27,
        "class": "Footnote",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0879,
          0.8578,
          0.3369,
          0.9055
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          139.1,
          1756.8,
          533.3,
          1854.5
        ],
        "text": "_PROPL ’25, Singapore, Singapore_\n© 2025 Copyright held by the owner/author(s).\nACM ISBN 979-8-4007-2161-8/25/10\nhttps://doi.org/10.1145/3759536.3763802"
      },
      {
        "page": 1,
        "order": 28,
        "class": "Page-footer",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.4951,
          0.9477,
          0.5039,
          0.9563
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          783.7,
          1940.9,
          797.7,
          1958.5
        ],
        "text": "8"
      }
    ],
    [
      {
        "page": 2,
        "order": 0,
        "class": "Page-header",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0879,
          0.0609,
          0.9111,
          0.0719
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          139.1,
          124.7,
          1442.3,
          147.3
        ],
        "text": "PROPL '25, October 12–18, 2025, Singapore, Singapore Cyrus Omar, Michael Coblenz, and Anil Madhavapeddy"
      },
      {
        "page": 2,
        "order": 1,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5195,
          0.093,
          0.9141,
          0.4078
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          822.4,
          190.5,
          1447.0,
          835.2
        ],
        "text": "and whenever upstream data or models change) by Fairground's distributed parallelizing scheduler [31], which we call the _planetary compute engine_. Computations will leverage distributed hardware resources semi-automatically, with only the heaviest computations needing manual configuration. Computational resources, including CPUs, GPUs, and storage, will be contributed by participants and sponsors for use according to lightweight access policies (e.g. reserving a scientist's own individual and institutional hardware for the computations they author).\n\nDesign research emphasizes the value of reasonable defaults in shaping user behavior [22]. The central design goal that distinguishes Fairground from competing systems is that we aim for artifacts authored in or imported into Fairground to be FAIR, reproducible, and live by default. Fairground is targeted toward the needs of a graduate student without substantial formal training in computing whose primary goal is to finish their next paper, rather than on one willing to invest substantial extra labor into achieving these criteria, which is rarely incentivized or rewarded. Let us give an overview of how the proposed design will achieve this critical goal."
      },
      {
        "page": 2,
        "order": 2,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0879,
          0.0938,
          0.4814,
          0.2422
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          139.1,
          192.1,
          762.1,
          496.0
        ],
        "text": "_Open science_, in which data and analytic methods are made publicly available, is a key technique for improving reproducibility. When scientific work is conducted openly, other scientists and members of the public can study the work, check the analysis for errors, and re-analyze the data using their own methods [53]. Scientists in many domains, including in biology [3], ecology [23], and at NASA [46] have argued that open science is a key technique for improving reproducibility of scientific work and addressing the reproducibility crisis."
      },
      {
        "page": 2,
        "order": 3,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5186,
          0.4359,
          0.9121,
          0.5
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          820.9,
          892.7,
          1443.9,
          1024.0
        ],
        "text": "**2 Design Considerations for Fairground**\nOur vision is inspired by the success of other collaborative commons [42], particularly Wikipedia [52], GitHub [28], and Google Earth Engine [19]."
      },
      {
        "page": 2,
        "order": 4,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5176,
          0.5273,
          0.7686,
          0.5422
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          819.4,
          1079.9,
          1216.7,
          1110.4
        ],
        "text": "2.1 Findability and Accessibility"
      },
      {
        "page": 2,
        "order": 5,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5176,
          0.5461,
          0.915,
          0.9062
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          819.4,
          1118.4,
          1448.4,
          1855.9
        ],
        "text": "On most existing platforms, notebooks are private by default, and substantial extra effort is needed to make them publicly findable and accessible by others who may benefit from their findings, functions, or pre-computed data (e.g. cleaned up versions of datasets). In Fairground, repositories will be public by default, closely following the example of GitHub, with opt-in access control to allow scientists to work with sensitive data. Each repository will receive a unique and persistent digital object identifier (DOI) [11] and be associated with its authors' ORCID identifiers [40] by default.\n\nCurrent repositories, such as those for oceanography [49], often include only data, not code, leaving scientists to re-implement analyses. Even when code is available in a repository such as Zenodo [12], it can be difficult to find and integrate into new contexts (e.g. due to outdated dependencies [43]).\n\nIn Fairground, the entire system forms a single live program, enabling Fairground to offer _semantic search_ affordances such as find-all-uses (e.g. of a dataset, so that a scientist can find others who have already cleaned up that dataset, or of a statistical function, so that a scientist can find examples of similar analyses) and find-all-implementations of a particular interface (e.g. a data schema or a statistical function signature)."
      },
      {
        "page": 2,
        "order": 6,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0889,
          0.2703,
          0.3271,
          0.2828
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          140.7,
          553.6,
          517.8,
          579.2
        ],
        "text": "**1.2   Towards live collaborations**"
      },
      {
        "page": 2,
        "order": 7,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0879,
          0.2898,
          0.4805,
          0.9055
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          139.1,
          593.5,
          764.5,
          1854.5
        ],
        "text": "Many fields of science, such as ecology and astronomy, are also _live_ collaborations: scientists continuously collect new data and refine modeling and analysis approaches. However, scientific models and analyses as reported in publications and scientific artifact repositories are frozen in time. Considerable extra effort and computational expertise possessed by few working scientists is needed to maintain **liveness** of analyses and models as new data are generated by sensors and experiments, and as upstream models and libraries improve. This leaves scientists and other stakeholders with a fragmented and outdated view of the state of the art [38]. We argue that _liveness_, in which the impact of program changes is visible immediately, promotes reuse because it enables programmers to more easily understand existing code and adapt it to their needs.\n\nWe envision an ambitious but practicable transition to a collaborative scientific workflow where thousands of scientists and other stakeholders, assisted in the future by safely sandboxed AI agents [39], work together within a _computational commons_—which we call Fairground—where thousands of scientific artifacts are authored, collected, and maintained together _in executable form_ in a manner that is FAIR, reproducible, and live _by default_. This vision goes beyond prior efforts focused on simple archival of data and code to emphasize live code execution and the development of interoperable software components, and echoes other recent calls for integrative scientific workflow systems.\n\nFairground will take the form of a collaborative computational notebook system that is as easy to use as competing platforms like JupyterLab or Google Earth Engine. It will consist of a collection of _computational notebooks_ and _data sources_ (including uploaded datasets and references to external datasets and streams) grouped into _repositories_ managed by participating individuals and organizations, much like on GitHub or GitLab (and we may indeed use a combination of these as our underlying version control platform).\n\nUnlike competing platforms, Fairground notebooks will be able to reference one another as libraries, collectively forming _a single planetary-scale live program_ being collaboratively edited in real-time or with optional lightweight version control, and executing live (i.e. as it is being edited",
        "bbox_detected_pixels": [
          139.1,
          593.5,
          760.6,
          1854.5
        ]
      },
      {
        "page": 2,
        "order": 8,
        "class": "Page-footer",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.4951,
          0.9469,
          0.5039,
          0.957
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          783.7,
          1939.3,
          797.7,
          1959.9
        ],
        "text": "9"
      }
    ],
    [
      {
        "page": 3,
        "order": 0,
        "class": "Page-header",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0879,
          0.0609,
          0.9111,
          0.0719
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          139.1,
          124.7,
          1442.3,
          147.3
        ],
        "text": "A FAIR Case for a Live Computational Commons PROPL '25, October 12–18, 2025, Singapore, Singapore"
      },
      {
        "page": 3,
        "order": 1,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0869,
          0.0938,
          0.4824,
          0.2875
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          137.6,
          192.1,
          763.6,
          588.8
        ],
        "text": "In addition to being able to access Fairground resources through a web browser, Fairground will offer an API so external applications can also access computational results. This will be particularly useful because Fairground is a live system: many results on Fairground will update continuously as new data are collected. Live data and visualizations maintained on Fairground might feed into external, public-facing projects, e.g. news articles or websites for public interest organizations; these feeds have been found to promote innovation in news media [2]. Users of these systems will be able to follow these embedded results back to their sources on Fairground, potentially increasing public trust in the results by inviting public scrutiny [36]."
      },
      {
        "page": 3,
        "order": 2,
        "class": "Section-header",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0869,
          0.3008,
          0.4785,
          0.3141
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          137.6,
          616.0,
          757.5,
          643.3
        ],
        "text": "2.2 **Interoperability, Reusability, and Reproducibility**"
      },
      {
        "page": 3,
        "order": 3,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0869,
          0.3203,
          0.4814,
          0.9062
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          137.6,
          656.0,
          762.1,
          1855.9
        ],
        "text": "Computational notebooks typically operate as scripts; they cannot be understood as libraries that can be accessed from other notebooks (without wastefully re-executing them in their entirety in the new context). It requires enormous extra effort for a scientist to create reusable libraries and contribute them to public library repositories like pip [47] or CRAN [1]. Consequently, it is common for scientists to re-implement behavior when they need an analysis that is not already in public package repositories. Reimplementing complex techniques can be error-prone, especially for non-experts who may not appreciate subtleties related to numerical accuracy [18] or leave statistical assumptions unchecked [16]. It is common to then copy-and-paste this functionality into each subsequent notebook where it might be useful, leading to messy and difficult-to-maintain code: 70% of all code snippets in Jupyter notebooks on GitHub are copies of other snippets [25].\nOn Fairground, every notebook is by default a library that exports its top-level definitions, including data and functions. Because the entire system operates as a single live program, importing one library into another does not require re-execution. This eliminates the process of packaging functionality into explicit libraries and submitting them to repositories—everything is immediately available for reuse across Fairground.\nTo enable this sort of open reuse, Fairground cannot permit the importing notebook to modify the state of the imported notebook's analyses. Consequently, a central feature of Fairground is the development of Fair Python, a pure (i.e. immutable, functional) dataflow subset of Python that will serve as the native language of Fairground. Pure dataflow is fundamentally the same model used by spreadsheets: programs consist of elements that compute results, potentially on the basis of results produced by other parts of the program. Spreadsheets require that these elements be in a grid and restrict the kinds of computations that can be done; Fair Python will relax these constraints, allowing general-purpose computation. Pure dataflow programming is already in wide use in scientific code beyond spreadsheets, e.g. it is"
      },
      {
        "page": 3,
        "order": 4,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5195,
          0.093,
          0.9141,
          0.6953
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          822.4,
          190.5,
          1447.0,
          1424.0
        ],
        "text": "the computational model underlying libraries like pandas for Python [34], and most pandas code will be expressible in Fair Python without modification. By avoiding ephemeral state, we ensure that Fair Python programs have reproducible outputs.\n\nOf course, we do not expect scientists to (re)write all code in a restricted subset of Python—in reality, scientific code is written in a wide variety of languages, including scripting languages like Python, R, and Julia and native languages like C, C++ and Fortran. While we will design Fair Python to be a highly usable language for new scientific developments, we do not expect scientists working in Fairground to port existing code _en masse_ to Fair Python. Instead, we will develop a _pure foreign function interface_ (FFI) for Fair Python that adds _foreign nodes_ to the dataflow, which support executing code written in any language. To maintain liveness and interoperability, foreign nodes are restricted only in that they execute within a sandboxed environment and their inputs and outputs must be pure data. For example, a node might pass data and parameters from elsewhere on Fairground into an existing optimized numerical simulation package written in Fortran, then specify that the dataset generated when the simulation ends (e.g. saved to a file in the sandboxed file system) is an output value. Each sandboxed environment is configured using the Nix package manager, which produces reproducible execution environments. This solves the common problem scientists face of interoperating with code that requires old or conflicting versions of packages.\n\nTo simplify common use cases, Fairground will be able to import existing Jupyter notebooks directly without modification, allowing them to be edited using the Jupyter web interface and automatically provisioning the necessary foreign node internally. Top-level definitions will be exported as outputs, and to maintain reproducibility, Fairground will persistently store the ephemeral state of each notebook. For native packages (those compiled for specific configurations from languages such as C++ or Fortran), we will require Nix configurations, which are written in a simple syntax that is widely documented. These configurations will be part of Fairground, so they can be reused by other scientists."
      },
      {
        "page": 3,
        "order": 5,
        "class": "Section-header",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5205,
          0.7242,
          0.6182,
          0.7359
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          824.0,
          1483.2,
          978.6,
          1507.1
        ],
        "text": "2.3 **Liveness**"
      },
      {
        "page": 3,
        "order": 6,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5195,
          0.7422,
          0.9121,
          0.9055
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          822.4,
          1520.0,
          1443.9,
          1854.5
        ],
        "text": "In traditional Python code, lines of code must be executed in order. This makes it difficult to leverage multicore hardware, which is ubiquitous even on laptops. Fairground eliminates these unnecessary sequential dependencies and automatically distributes computations, and live recomputations, for parallel execution across users' individual cores as well as computational resources contributed by participants. We call this system the Fairground _planetary compute engine_ [15].\nThe commons will centralize thousands of data and code artifacts, which will have permanent identifiers that can be referenced from papers and other permanent artifacts, and"
      },
      {
        "page": 3,
        "order": 7,
        "class": "Page-footer",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.4922,
          0.9469,
          0.5068,
          0.957
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          779.2,
          1939.3,
          802.3,
          1959.9
        ],
        "text": "10"
      }
    ],
    [
      {
        "page": 4,
        "order": 0,
        "class": "Page-header",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0879,
          0.0617,
          0.9111,
          0.0711
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          139.1,
          126.4,
          1442.3,
          145.6
        ],
        "text": "PROPL '25, October 12–18, 2025, Singapore, Singapore Cyrus Omar, Michael Coblenz, and Anil Madhavapeddy"
      },
      {
        "page": 4,
        "order": 1,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0869,
          0.0938,
          0.4824,
          0.2109
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          137.6,
          192.1,
          763.6,
          431.9
        ],
        "text": "can be searched to find relevant code and data. It will be open-source, enabling long-term maintenance and transparency of policies and behavior. It will support a distributed storage model, enabling both centralized, persistent storage and local replicas for high performance and customized access when needed. It will interoperate with other sources of data, such as NASA's PO.DAAC [24] and support computation in a variety of different languages."
      },
      {
        "page": 4,
        "order": 2,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0869,
          0.2148,
          0.4834,
          0.2719
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          137.6,
          439.9,
          765.2,
          556.9
        ],
        "text": "Because Fairground programs will be live, it will seam-\nlessly support reusability; any computation can be run, mod-\nified, and re-used in new contexts, even by users who have\nvery different local computational infrastructure."
      },
      {
        "page": 4,
        "order": 3,
        "class": "Section-header",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0889,
          0.3,
          0.4092,
          0.3125
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          140.7,
          614.4,
          647.8,
          640.0
        ],
        "text": "2.4 Next Steps Towards Live Programming"
      },
      {
        "page": 4,
        "order": 4,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0869,
          0.3195,
          0.4814,
          0.5727
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          137.6,
          654.3,
          762.1,
          1172.9
        ],
        "text": "In summary, we propose three interleaved tracks of research that, together, will result in an operational prototype of a next-generation collaborative scientific workflow system. The proposed research will, in the process, lead to significant advances in the field of human-centered programming language design and implementation. In the first track, we will focus on the design and implementation of Fair Python. In the second, we will focus on interoperability with external data sources and code written in existing languages. In the third, we will advance the underlying planetary compute engine so that Fairground can scale to planetary-size datasets and analyses. We have already developed an operational prototype of the web-based user interface in the Hazel research programming environment [37] and plan, as a plenary approach, to integrate the research advances from all three tracks into this prototype, evolving it directly into Fairground."
      },
      {
        "page": 4,
        "order": 5,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0869,
          0.5758,
          0.4805,
          0.6633
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          137.6,
          1179.2,
          760.6,
          1358.4
        ],
        "text": "To ensure that Fairground is as usable as possible for scien-\ntists, all three tracks will follow a _participatory design process_,\nfollowing best practices for language design in which we\niteratively make and evaluate design choices [9] with the\nspecific goal of improving real-world scientific workflows\nbeing performed by scientists."
      },
      {
        "page": 4,
        "order": 6,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0869,
          0.6664,
          0.4824,
          0.8141
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          137.6,
          1364.8,
          763.6,
          1667.3
        ],
        "text": "We will leverage our existing connections to involve sci-\nentists from several disciplines, with an initial focus on\noceanography. In particular, we plan to develop case studies\nfrom the work of collaborators in the fields of oceanography\nand biology, and co-author Anil Madhavapeddy at the Uni-\nversity of Cambridge. We will start with laptop-scale case\nstudies from domain-specific data science courses with mini-\nmal external dependencies and then continue with full-scale\ncase studies drawn from scientific research papers, ongoing\nprojects, and graduate courses."
      },
      {
        "page": 4,
        "order": 7,
        "class": "Section-header",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0869,
          0.843,
          0.377,
          0.8555
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          137.6,
          1726.5,
          596.8,
          1752.1
        ],
        "text": "**3 Discussion and Related Work**"
      },
      {
        "page": 4,
        "order": 8,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0869,
          0.8641,
          0.4795,
          0.9047
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          137.6,
          1769.7,
          759.0,
          1852.8
        ],
        "text": "Encouragingly, our research direction into FAIR and live planetary computing is complemented by several ongoing efforts across the world, which we will discuss next."
      },
      {
        "page": 4,
        "order": 9,
        "class": "Section-header",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5195,
          0.0945,
          0.6855,
          0.1039
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          822.4,
          193.5,
          1085.1,
          212.8
        ],
        "text": "**3.1 Future Directions**"
      },
      {
        "page": 4,
        "order": 10,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5186,
          0.1125,
          0.9131,
          0.3359
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          820.9,
          230.4,
          1445.4,
          687.9
        ],
        "text": "We are currently working on a working prototype of Fairground, validated through a series of increasingly complex case studies and user studies. We anticipate that Fairground will first be ready for use by early adopters in the scientific community. At this point, we hope to continue development of Fairground by pursuing funding to develop a non-profit governance organization, guided by the TRUST principles [26], that will support both further technical development and, most importantly, develop the community around Fairground. While our initial focus will be on oceanography [21], biodiversity [5, 14] and forest protection [45] related case studies, we will broaden the scope of the project to other scientific communities at this time (and potentially earlier if opportunities arise). Our goal is for Fairground to be the most usable platform for doing day-to-day open science."
      },
      {
        "page": 4,
        "order": 11,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5195,
          0.3391,
          0.9141,
          0.4695
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          822.4,
          694.5,
          1447.0,
          961.5
        ],
        "text": "We anticipate that AI systems will be capable of assist-\ning in the large-scale ingestion of existing computational\nnotebooks and datasets into the Fairground system toward\nthe end of the funding period, which we believe will help us\nbootstrap it to the point that it is quickly useful to working\nscientists rather than just early adopters. We believe that\nthe time is right for scientific workflows to move to a next-\ngeneration platform designed with both usability and the\nFAIR criteria in mind from the start."
      },
      {
        "page": 4,
        "order": 12,
        "class": "Section-header",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5205,
          0.4883,
          0.8838,
          0.5008
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          824.0,
          1000.0,
          1399.1,
          1025.6
        ],
        "text": "3.2 Related Planetary Computing Infrastructure"
      },
      {
        "page": 4,
        "order": 13,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5186,
          0.507,
          0.915,
          0.6703
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          820.9,
          1038.3,
          1448.4,
          1372.8
        ],
        "text": "Our approach is motivated by multidisciplinary calls to de-\nvelop tools that make it easier to follow FAIR practices for\nlarge-scale collaborative science and handle planetary-scale\ndata and computation. Co-author Anil Madhavapeddy and\ncolleagues in conservation made a case for “_planetary com-\nputing_ — infrastructure to handle the ingestion, transfor-\nmation, analysis, and publication of global data products\nfor furthering environmental science and enabling better\ninformed policy-making” [15]. This article explains that sci-\nentists need access to large petabyte-scale input datasets\nconsisting of:"
      },
      {
        "page": 4,
        "order": 14,
        "class": "List-item",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5439,
          0.6781,
          0.9209,
          0.7047
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          861.0,
          1388.7,
          1457.8,
          1443.2
        ],
        "text": "• primary observation data from satellites that is petabyte-\nscale or direct ground measurements;"
      },
      {
        "page": 4,
        "order": 15,
        "class": "List-item",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5449,
          0.7086,
          0.9121,
          0.7344
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          862.6,
          1451.2,
          1443.9,
          1504.1
        ],
        "text": "- derived sources from algorithmic transformation or\n  AI-based inference;"
      },
      {
        "page": 4,
        "order": 16,
        "class": "List-item",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5459,
          0.7391,
          0.9102,
          0.7641
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          864.2,
          1513.7,
          1440.8,
          1564.9
        ],
        "text": "- previous results derived by third parties or from earlier runs"
      },
      {
        "page": 4,
        "order": 17,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5176,
          0.7727,
          0.9141,
          0.8586
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          819.4,
          1582.5,
          1447.0,
          1758.4
        ],
        "text": "Programmers then define computation over these datasets that: (i) is either algorithmic or machine learning-based, using a mix of CPUs and GPUs; (ii) needs to autoscale to permit local development followed by global analysis; and (iii) can be expressed by a non-CS expert, ideally with a visual interface."
      },
      {
        "page": 4,
        "order": 18,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5186,
          0.8641,
          0.9121,
          0.9055
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          820.9,
          1769.7,
          1443.9,
          1854.5
        ],
        "text": "The Global Biodiversity Information Facility observed: “There has been an explosion of data and information, and a concomitant paradigm shift to data-driven research and"
      },
      {
        "page": 4,
        "order": 19,
        "class": "Page-footer",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.4922,
          0.9477,
          0.5068,
          0.9563
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          779.2,
          1940.9,
          802.3,
          1958.5
        ],
        "text": "11"
      }
    ],
    [
      {
        "page": 5,
        "order": 0,
        "class": "Page-header",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0869,
          0.0617,
          0.9111,
          0.0711
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          137.6,
          126.4,
          1442.3,
          145.6
        ],
        "text": "A FAIR Case for a Live Computational Commons PROPL '25, October 12–18, 2025, Singapore, Singapore"
      },
      {
        "page": 5,
        "order": 1,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0879,
          0.0945,
          0.4814,
          0.1656
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          139.1,
          193.5,
          762.1,
          339.1
        ],
        "text": "specifically biodiversity research and its myriad applications. [...] Redesigned scientific data organizations [...] are developing approaches designed specifically to take advantage of the unprecedented data opportunities in a cooperative framework\" [10]."
      },
      {
        "page": 5,
        "order": 2,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0879,
          0.1703,
          0.4824,
          0.3023
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          139.1,
          348.8,
          763.6,
          619.1
        ],
        "text": "Participants at NCAR's Workshop on Correctness and Re-\nproducibility for Climate and Weather Software [32] sought\nsolutions for reproducibility problems. Running analyses\non multiple systems results in discrepancies; our approach\nenables scientists to reuse common computations and re-\nsults. At the 1st Programming for the Planet workshop [27],\nCimadevilla argued [8] that acquisition and processing of\ndata from heterogeneous data sources, followed by reuse of\nmodel outputs, is a key component of many scientific tasks."
      },
      {
        "page": 5,
        "order": 3,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0879,
          0.3055,
          0.4805,
          0.5867
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          139.1,
          625.7,
          764.5,
          1201.6
        ],
        "text": "Large enterprises have also recognized the need for commonly available computational infrastructure for earth science. In particular, Google offers the Google Earth Engine product [19] and Microsoft offers the Microsoft Planetary Computer [29] product upon request to environmental scientists. These tools allow scientists to develop computational notebooks and execute them using cloud hardware that has access to a common repository of data sets and software packages, much like our proposed system. However, as explained above, notebooks in these tools are not **FAIR**, not **reproducible**, and not **live**. The research described here may help these organizations address these problems for their proprietary planetary compute engines. We will instead lay the intellectual groundwork for a fully open complement to these platforms. Encouragingly, we can build upon emerging open and federated standards being established by initiatives such as OpenEO [30], which defines APIs independent of any single cloud provider or organization for the processing of earth observation data.",
        "bbox_detected_pixels": [
          139.1,
          625.7,
          760.6,
          1201.6
        ]
      },
      {
        "page": 5,
        "order": 4,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0879,
          0.5922,
          0.4824,
          0.7828
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          139.1,
          1212.8,
          763.6,
          1603.2
        ],
        "text": "The most closely related effort to build a computational commons for scientists is the Observable community [35], which hosts a computational commons with support for **live** evaluation within individual notebooks (though not across notebooks). Notebooks can refer to explicitly exported values in other notebooks, which must be pure. The analyses must be written in JavaScript and run in the user's browser. While there is some support for controlling side effects, these are opt-in, so the system lacks **reproducibility** and automatic scalability. Although Observable does not meet our criteria, it demonstrates that it is possible to attract communities of users to a well-designed and curated computational commons."
      },
      {
        "page": 5,
        "order": 5,
        "class": "Section-header",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0889,
          0.8008,
          0.1846,
          0.8117
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          140.7,
          1640.0,
          292.2,
          1662.4
        ],
        "text": "**References**"
      },
      {
        "page": 5,
        "order": 6,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0938,
          0.8203,
          0.4795,
          0.8422
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          148.5,
          1680.0,
          759.0,
          1724.8
        ],
        "text": "[1] INSTITUTE FOR STATISTICS AND MATHEMATICS. The comprehensive r archive network. https://cran.r-project.org, 2025."
      },
      {
        "page": 5,
        "order": 7,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0947,
          0.8453,
          0.4805,
          0.8797
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          149.9,
          1731.2,
          760.6,
          1801.6
        ],
        "text": "[2] AITAMURTO, T., AND LEWIS, S. C. Open innovation in digital journalism: Examining the impact of open apis at four news organizations. _New media & society_ 15, 2 (2013), 314–331."
      },
      {
        "page": 5,
        "order": 8,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0938,
          0.8836,
          0.4785,
          0.9055
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          148.5,
          1809.6,
          757.5,
          1854.5
        ],
        "text": "[3] ALLEN, C., AND MEHLER, D. M. Open science challenges, benefits and tips in early career and beyond. *PLoS biology* *17*, 5 (2019), e3000246."
      },
      {
        "page": 5,
        "order": 9,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5254,
          0.0961,
          0.9121,
          0.118
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          831.7,
          196.8,
          1443.9,
          241.7
        ],
        "text": "[4] BAKER, M. 1,500 scientists lift the lid on reproducibility. _Nature_ 533, 7604 (2016)."
      },
      {
        "page": 5,
        "order": 10,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5254,
          0.1211,
          0.9131,
          0.1555
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          831.7,
          248.0,
          1445.4,
          318.5
        ],
        "text": "[5] BALL, T., DALES, M., EYRES, A., GREEN, J., MADHAVAPEDDY, A., WILLIAMS, D., and BALMFORD, A. Quantifying the impact of the food we eat on species extinctions, feb 2025."
      },
      {
        "page": 5,
        "order": 11,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5264,
          0.1586,
          0.9131,
          0.2164
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          833.3,
          324.8,
          1445.4,
          443.2
        ],
        "text": "[6] BARKER, M., CHUE HONG, N. P., KATZ, D. S., LAMPRECHT, A.-L., MARTINEZ-ORTIZ, C., PSOMOPOULOS, F., HARROW, J., CASTRO, L. J., GRUENPETER, M., MARTINEZ, P. A., and HONEYMAN, T. Introducing the FAIR Principles for research software. _Scientific Data_ 9, 1 (2022), 622."
      },
      {
        "page": 5,
        "order": 12,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5244,
          0.2219,
          0.9141,
          0.2812
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          830.1,
          454.5,
          1447.0,
          575.9
        ],
        "text": "[7] CAMERER, C. F., DREBER, A., FORSELL, E., HO, T.-H., HUBER, J., JOHANNESSON, M., KIRCHLER, M., ALMENBERG, J., ALTMEJD, A., CHAN, T., HEIKENSTEN, E., HOLZMEISTER, F., IMAI, T., ISAKSSON, S., NAVE, G., PFEIFFER, T., RAZEN, M., and WU, H. Evaluating replicability of laboratory experiments in economics. _Science_ 351, 6280 (2016), 1433–1436."
      },
      {
        "page": 5,
        "order": 13,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5254,
          0.2844,
          0.9131,
          0.3063
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          831.7,
          582.5,
          1445.4,
          627.3
        ],
        "text": "[8] CIMADEVILLA, E. The programming challenges of climate data analysis. In _Programming for the Planet_ (2024)."
      },
      {
        "page": 5,
        "order": 14,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5234,
          0.3094,
          0.9131,
          0.357
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          828.5,
          633.7,
          1445.4,
          731.1
        ],
        "text": "[9] COBLENZ, M., KAMBHATLA, G., KORONKEVICH, P., WISE, J. L., BARNABY, C., SUNSHINE, J., ALDRICH, J., AND MYERS, B. A. PLIERS: A process that integrates user-centered methods into programming language design. _ACM Trans. Comput.-Hum. Interact._ 28, 4 (jul 2021)."
      },
      {
        "page": 5,
        "order": 15,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5195,
          0.3602,
          0.9102,
          0.382
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          822.4,
          737.7,
          1440.8,
          782.3
        ],
        "text": "[10] CODATA, T. C. O. D. O. T. I. S. C., PFEIFFENBERGER, H., UHLIR, P., AND HODSON, S. Twenty-Year Review of GBIF, May 2020."
      },
      {
        "page": 5,
        "order": 16,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5186,
          0.3852,
          0.9131,
          0.4062
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          820.9,
          788.9,
          1445.4,
          831.9
        ],
        "text": "[11] DOI FOUNDATION. What is a DOI. https://www.doi.org/the-identifier/what-is-a-doi/, 2022."
      },
      {
        "page": 5,
        "order": 17,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5195,
          0.4102,
          0.9131,
          0.432
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          822.4,
          840.1,
          1445.4,
          884.7
        ],
        "text": "[12] EUROPEAN ORGANIZATION FOR NUCLEAR RESEARCH, and OpenAIRE. Zenodo, 2013."
      },
      {
        "page": 5,
        "order": 18,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5195,
          0.4359,
          0.9121,
          0.4828
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          822.4,
          892.7,
          1443.9,
          988.8
        ],
        "text": "[13] EYRES, A., BALL, T., DALES, M., SWINFIELD, T., ARNELL, A., BAISERO, D., DURÁN, A. P., GREEN, J., GREEN, R. E., AND MADHAVAPEDDY, A. LIFE: A metric for quantitively mapping the impact of land-cover change on global extinctions. _Cambridge Open Engage_ (2024)."
      },
      {
        "page": 5,
        "order": 19,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5195,
          0.4859,
          0.9121,
          0.5461
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          822.4,
          995.1,
          1443.9,
          1118.4
        ],
        "text": "[14] EYRES, A., BALL, T. S., DALES, M., SWINFIELD, T., ARNELL, A., BAISERO, D., DURAJN, A. P., GREEN, J. M. H., GREEN, R., MADHAVAPEDDY, A., AND BALMFORD, A. LIFE: A metric for mapping the impact of land-cover change on global extinctions. _Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences_ 380, 2017 (jan 2025), 1–13."
      },
      {
        "page": 5,
        "order": 20,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5195,
          0.5484,
          0.9131,
          0.5961
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          822.4,
          1123.1,
          1445.4,
          1220.8
        ],
        "text": "[15] FERRIS, P., DALES, M., JAFFER, S., HOLCOMB, A., SCOTT, E. T., SWINFIELD, T., EYRES, A., BALMFORD, A., COOMES, D., KESHAV, S., AND MADHAVAPEDDY, A. Planetary computing for data-driven environmental policy-making, 2024."
      },
      {
        "page": 5,
        "order": 21,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5195,
          0.5992,
          0.9131,
          0.6211
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          822.4,
          1227.2,
          1445.4,
          1272.0
        ],
        "text": "[16] GARDENIER, J., AND AND, D. R. The misuse of statistics: Concepts, tools, and a research agenda. _Accountability in Research_ 9, 2 (2002), 65–74."
      },
      {
        "page": 5,
        "order": 22,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5195,
          0.6242,
          0.9121,
          0.6461
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          822.4,
          1278.4,
          1443.9,
          1323.2
        ],
        "text": "[17] GOBLE, C. Better software, better research. _IEEE Internet Computing_ 18, 5 (2014), 4–8."
      },
      {
        "page": 5,
        "order": 23,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5195,
          0.6492,
          0.9121,
          0.682
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          822.4,
          1329.6,
          1443.9,
          1396.7
        ],
        "text": "[18] **GOLDBERG**, D. What every computer scientist should know about floating-point arithmetic. _ACM computing surveys_ (CSUR) 23, 1 (1991), 5–48."
      },
      {
        "page": 5,
        "order": 24,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5195,
          0.6875,
          0.7373,
          0.6969
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          822.4,
          1408.0,
          1167.1,
          1427.3
        ],
        "text": "[19] GOOGLE. Google earth engine, 2024."
      },
      {
        "page": 5,
        "order": 25,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5195,
          0.7,
          0.9131,
          0.782
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          822.4,
          1433.6,
          1445.4,
          1601.5
        ],
        "text": "[20] GUIBOURD DE LUZINAIS, V., DU PONTAVICE, H., REYGONDEAU, G., BARRIER, N., BLANCHARD, J. L., BORNAEL, V., BÜCHNER, M., CHEUNG, W. W. L., EDDY, T. D., EVERETT, J. D., GUET, J., HARRISON, C. S., MAURY, O., NOVAGLIO, C., PETRIK, C. M., STEENBEEK, J., TITTENSOR, D. P., AND GASCUel, D. Trophic amplification: A model intercomparison of climate driven changes in marine food webs. _PLOS ONE_ 18, 8 (08 2023), 1–23."
      },
      {
        "page": 5,
        "order": 26,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5195,
          0.7883,
          0.9131,
          0.8469
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          822.4,
          1614.4,
          1445.4,
          1734.5
        ],
        "text": "[21] Haine, T. W. N., Gelderloos, R., Jimenez-Urias, M. A., Siddiqui, A. H., Lemson, G., Medvedev, D., Szalay, A., Abernathey, R. P., Almansy, M., and Hill, C. N. Is computational oceanography coming of age? _Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society_ 102, 8 (Aug. 2021), E1481–E1493."
      },
      {
        "page": 5,
        "order": 27,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5195,
          0.8508,
          0.9131,
          0.8844
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          822.4,
          1742.4,
          1445.4,
          1811.3
        ],
        "text": "[22] **JACHIMOWICZ, J. M., DUNCAN, S., WEBER, E. U., AND JOHNSON, E. J.** When and why defaults influence decisions: A meta-analysis of default effects. _Behavioural Public Policy_ 3, 2 (2019), 159–186."
      },
      {
        "page": 5,
        "order": 28,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5195,
          0.8883,
          0.9131,
          0.8977
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          822.4,
          1819.2,
          1445.4,
          1838.5
        ],
        "text": "[23] JENKINS, G. B., BECKERMAN, A. P., BELLARD, C., BENÍTEZ-LÓPEZ, A.,"
      },
      {
        "page": 5,
        "order": 29,
        "class": "Page-footer",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.4932,
          0.9477,
          0.5059,
          0.9563
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          780.7,
          1940.9,
          800.8,
          1958.5
        ],
        "text": "12"
      }
    ],
    [
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 0,
        "class": "Page-header",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0879,
          0.0617,
          0.9111,
          0.0719
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          139.1,
          126.4,
          1442.3,
          147.3
        ],
        "text": "PROPL '25, October 12–18, 2025, Singapore, Singapore        Cyrus Omar, Michael Coblenz, and Anil Madhavapeddy"
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 1,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.1152,
          0.0961,
          0.4814,
          0.168
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          182.4,
          196.8,
          762.1,
          344.1
        ],
        "text": "ELLISON, A. M., FOOTE, C. G., HUFTON, A. L., LASHLEY, M. A., LORTIE, C. J., MA, Z., MOORE, A. J., NARUM, S. R., NILSSON, J., O'BOYLE, B., PROVETE, D. B., RAZGOUR, O., RIESEBERG, L., RIGINOS, C., SANTINI, L., SIBBET, B., and PERES-NETO, P. R. Reproducibility in ecology and evolution: Minimum standards for data and code. _Ecology and Evolution_ 13, 5 (2023), e9961."
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 2,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0889,
          0.1719,
          0.4795,
          0.1922
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          140.7,
          352.1,
          759.0,
          393.6
        ],
        "text": "[24] JET PROPULSION LABORATORY. Physical oceanography distributed active archive center, 2025."
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 3,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0889,
          0.1969,
          0.4824,
          0.2313
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          140.7,
          403.3,
          763.6,
          473.7
        ],
        "text": "[25] KÄLLÉN, M., AND WRIGSTAD, T. Jupyter notebooks on GitHub: Charac- teristics and code clones. _The Art, Science, and Engineering of Program- ming_ 5 (2021)."
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 4,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0889,
          0.2344,
          0.4805,
          0.2687
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          140.7,
          480.1,
          760.6,
          550.3
        ],
        "text": "[26] LIN, D., CRABTREE, J., DILLO, I., DOWNS, R. R., EDMUNDS, R., GIARETTA, D., DE GIUSTI, M., L’HOURS, H., HUGO, W., AND JENKYS, R. The TRUST principles for digital repositories. _Scientific Data_ 7, 1 (2020), 1–5."
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 5,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0889,
          0.2719,
          0.4805,
          0.2922
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          140.7,
          556.9,
          760.6,
          598.4
        ],
        "text": "[27] MADHAVAPEDDY, A., AND ORCHARD, D. Programming for the planet, 2024."
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 6,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0889,
          0.2969,
          0.2559,
          0.3063
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          140.7,
          608.1,
          405.1,
          627.3
        ],
        "text": "[28] MICROSOFT. GitHub, 2024."
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 7,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0889,
          0.3102,
          0.375,
          0.3195
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          140.7,
          635.3,
          593.6,
          654.3
        ],
        "text": "[29] MICROSOFT. Microsoft planetary computer, 2024."
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 8,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0889,
          0.3227,
          0.4805,
          0.3695
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          140.7,
          660.9,
          760.6,
          756.7
        ],
        "text": "[30] MOHR, M., PEBESMA, E., DRIES, J., LIPPENS, S., JANSSEN, B., THIEX, D., MILCINSKI, G., SCHUMACHER, B., BRIESE, C., CLAUS, M., ET AL. Federated and reusable processing of earth observation data. _Scientific Data_ 12, 1 (2025), 194."
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 9,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0889,
          0.3727,
          0.4805,
          0.4203
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          140.7,
          763.3,
          760.6,
          860.8
        ],
        "text": "[31] MURRAY, D. G., SCHWARZKOPF, M., SMOWTON, C., SMITH, S., MADHAVAPEDDY, A., AND HAND, S. CIEL: A universal execution engine for distributed data-flow computing. In _8th USENIX Symposium on Networked Systems Design and Implementation_ (NSDI 11) (mar 2011)."
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 10,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0889,
          0.4234,
          0.4814,
          0.4453
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          140.7,
          867.1,
          762.1,
          912.0
        ],
        "text": "[32] National Center for Atmospheric Research. Workshop on correctness and reproducibility for climate and weather software, 2023."
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 11,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0889,
          0.4484,
          0.4805,
          0.5078
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          140.7,
          918.3,
          760.6,
          1040.0
        ],
        "text": "[33] NGUYEN-HOAN, L., FLINT, S., AND SANKARANARAYANA, R. A survey of scientific software development. In _Proceedings of the 2010 ACM-IEEE International Symposium on Empirical Software Engineering and Measurement_ (New York, NY, USA, 2010), ESEM '10, Association for Computing Machinery."
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 12,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0889,
          0.5109,
          0.4258,
          0.5203
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          140.7,
          1046.3,
          674.0,
          1065.6
        ],
        "text": "[34] NumFOCUS, Inc. pandas. https://pandas.pydata.org, 2025."
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 13,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0889,
          0.5242,
          0.4229,
          0.5336
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          140.7,
          1073.6,
          669.5,
          1092.8
        ],
        "text": "[35] **OBSERVABLE**. Observable. https://www.observablehq.com."
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 14,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0889,
          0.5367,
          0.4805,
          0.5836
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          140.7,
          1099.2,
          760.6,
          1195.2
        ],
        "text": "[36] O'HARA, K. Transparency, open data and trust in government: shaping the infosphere. In _Proceedings of the 4th Annual ACM Web Science Conference_ (New York, NY, USA, 2012), WebSci '12, Association for Computing Machinery, p. 223–232."
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 15,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0889,
          0.5867,
          0.3271,
          0.5961
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          140.7,
          1201.6,
          517.8,
          1220.8
        ],
        "text": "[37] OMAR, C. Hazel. https://hazel.org, 2025."
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 16,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0889,
          0.5992,
          0.4805,
          0.6461
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          140.7,
          1227.2,
          760.6,
          1323.2
        ],
        "text": "[38] OMAR, C., ALDRICH, J., AND GERKIN, R. C. Collaborative infrastructure for test-driven scientific model validation. In _Companion proceedings of the 36th international conference on software engineering_ (2014), pp. 524–527."
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 17,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.0889,
          0.6492,
          0.4785,
          0.6586
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          140.7,
          1329.6,
          757.5,
          1348.8
        ],
        "text": "[39] OMAR, C., FERRIS, P., AND MADHAVAPEDDY, A. Modularizing reasoning"
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 18,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5469,
          0.0953,
          0.9121,
          0.1305
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          865.7,
          195.2,
          1443.9,
          267.3
        ],
        "text": "about AI capabilities via abstract dijkstra monads. In _the 12th ACM SIGPLAN Workshop on Higher-Order Programming with Effects_ (HOPE) (sep 2024)."
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 19,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5195,
          0.1336,
          0.9131,
          0.1539
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          822.4,
          273.6,
          1445.4,
          315.2
        ],
        "text": "[40] OPEN RESEARCHER AND CONTRIBUTOR ID. ORCID. https://orcid.org, 2025."
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 20,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5195,
          0.1594,
          0.9141,
          0.2188
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          822.4,
          326.5,
          1447.0,
          448.1
        ],
        "text": "[41] PRABHU, P., JABLIN, T. B., RAMAN, A., ZHANG, Y., HUANG, J., KIM, H., JOHNSON, N. P., LIU, F., GHOSH, S., BEARD, S., OH, T., ZOUFALY, M., WALKER, D., AND AUGUST, D. I. A survey of the practice of computational science. In _State of the Practice Reports_ (New York, NY, USA, 2011), SC ’11, Association for Computing Machinery."
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 21,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5205,
          0.2219,
          0.9131,
          0.2539
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          824.0,
          454.5,
          1445.4,
          520.0
        ],
        "text": "[42] RIFKIN, J. _The zero marginal cost society: The internet of things, the collaborative commons, and the eclipse of capitalism_. St. Martin's Press, 2014."
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 22,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5205,
          0.2594,
          0.9102,
          0.2812
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          824.0,
          531.3,
          1440.8,
          575.9
        ],
        "text": "[43] SAURO, H. M. The practice of ensuring repeatable and reproducible computational models, 2021."
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 23,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5195,
          0.2844,
          0.9111,
          0.318
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          822.4,
          582.5,
          1442.3,
          651.3
        ],
        "text": "[44] STORER, T. Bridging the chasm: A survey of software engineering practice in scientific programming. _ACM Comput. Surv._ 50, 4 (aug 2017)."
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 24,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5195,
          0.3203,
          0.9131,
          0.3547
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          822.4,
          656.0,
          1445.4,
          726.4
        ],
        "text": "[45] SWINFIELD, T., SHRIKANTH, S., BULL, J., MADHAVAPEDDY, A., AND ZU ERGMASSEN, S. Nature-based credit markets at a crossroads. _Nature Sustainability_ (aug 2024), 1–4."
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 25,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5195,
          0.3586,
          0.9111,
          0.3797
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          822.4,
          734.4,
          1442.3,
          777.6
        ],
        "text": "[46] The National Aeronautics and Space Administration. Open science at NASA, 2024."
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 26,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5195,
          0.3828,
          0.9121,
          0.4055
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          822.4,
          784.0,
          1443.9,
          830.5
        ],
        "text": "[47] THE PYTHON PACKAGING AUTHORITY. pip 25.0.1. https://pypi.org/project/pip/, 2025."
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 27,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5195,
          0.4086,
          0.9121,
          0.468
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          822.4,
          836.8,
          1443.9,
          958.5
        ],
        "text": "[48] TIWARI, K., KANANATHAN, S., ROBERTS, M. G., MEYER, J. P., SHARIF SOHAN, M. U., XAVIER, A., MAIRE, M., ZYOOD, A., MEN, J., NG, S., NGUYEN, T. V. N., GLONT, M., HERMJAKOB, H., AND MALIK-SHERIFF, R. S. Reproductibility in systems biology modelling. _Molecular systems biology_ 17, 2 (2021), e9982."
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 28,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5195,
          0.4711,
          0.9131,
          0.4938
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          822.4,
          964.8,
          1445.4,
          1011.3
        ],
        "text": "[49] U.S. NATIONAL SCIENCE FOUNDATION. OCE data and sample repositories. https://www.nsf.gov/geo/oce/data-sample-repositories, 2025."
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 29,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5195,
          0.4961,
          0.9131,
          0.5437
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          822.4,
          1016.0,
          1445.4,
          1113.5
        ],
        "text": "[50] VAN DENDEREN, D., MAUREAUD, A. A., ANDERSEN, K. H., GAICHAS, S., LINDEGREN, M., PETRIK, C. M., STOCK, C. A., AND COLLIE, J. Demersal fish biomass declines with temperature across productive shelf seas. _Global Ecology and Biogeography_ 32, 10 (2023), 1846–1857."
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 30,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5195,
          0.5469,
          0.9131,
          0.5813
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          822.4,
          1120.1,
          1445.4,
          1190.5
        ],
        "text": "[51] WIGGINS, B. J., AND CHRISTOPHERSON, C. D. The replication crisis in psychology: An overview for theoretical and philosophical psychology. _Journal of Theoretical and Philosophical Psychology_ 39 (2019), 202–217."
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 31,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5195,
          0.5844,
          0.7861,
          0.5938
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          822.4,
          1196.9,
          1244.4,
          1216.1
        ],
        "text": "[52] WIKIPEDIA CONTRIBUTORS. Wikipedia, 2024."
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 32,
        "class": "Bibliography",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5195,
          0.5969,
          0.9121,
          0.6445
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          822.4,
          1222.5,
          1443.9,
          1319.9
        ],
        "text": "[53] WILKINSON, M. D., DUMONTIER, M., AALBERSBERG, I. J., APPLETON, G., AXTON, M., BAAK, A., BLOMBERG, N., BOITEN, J.-W., DA SILVA SANTOS, L. B., AND BOURNE, P. E. The FAIR guiding principles for scientific data management and stewardship. _Scientific data_ 3, 1 (2016), 1–9."
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 33,
        "class": "Text",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.5186,
          0.6594,
          0.7686,
          0.6695
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          820.9,
          1350.5,
          1216.7,
          1371.1
        ],
        "text": "Received 2025-07-08; accepted 2025-08-11"
      },
      {
        "page": 6,
        "order": 34,
        "class": "Page-footer",
        "bbox_normalized": [
          0.4922,
          0.9477,
          0.5068,
          0.9563
        ],
        "bbox_pixels": [
          779.2,
          1940.9,
          802.3,
          1958.5
        ],
        "text": "13"
      }
    ]
  ],
  "layout_audit": [
    {
      "mode": "guarded",
      "selected": "detect",
      "detector": {
        "reference_chars": 4075,
        "covered_chars": 4072,
        "duplicate_chars": 0,
        "coverage": 0.9992638036809816
      },
      "guard": {
        "coverage": 0.95,
        "min_chars": 20,
        "min_gain": 0.005,
        "duplicate_tolerance": 0.001
      },
      "retry_attempted": false
    },
    {
      "mode": "guarded",
      "selected": "detect",
      "detector": {
        "reference_chars": 4996,
        "covered_chars": 4989,
        "duplicate_chars": 0,
        "coverage": 0.9985988791032826
      },
      "guard": {
        "coverage": 0.95,
        "min_chars": 20,
        "min_gain": 0.005,
        "duplicate_tolerance": 0.001
      },
      "retry_attempted": false,
      "snapped_boxes": [
        7
      ]
    },
    {
      "mode": "guarded",
      "selected": "full",
      "detector": {
        "reference_chars": 5218,
        "covered_chars": 4188,
        "duplicate_chars": 0,
        "coverage": 0.802606362591031
      },
      "guard": {
        "coverage": 0.95,
        "min_chars": 20,
        "min_gain": 0.005,
        "duplicate_tolerance": 0.001
      },
      "retry_attempted": true,
      "reason": "low_text_coverage",
      "full": {
        "reference_chars": 5218,
        "covered_chars": 5218,
        "duplicate_chars": 0,
        "coverage": 1.0
      }
    },
    {
      "mode": "guarded",
      "selected": "full",
      "detector": {
        "reference_chars": 4832,
        "covered_chars": 4214,
        "duplicate_chars": 0,
        "coverage": 0.8721026490066225
      },
      "guard": {
        "coverage": 0.95,
        "min_chars": 20,
        "min_gain": 0.005,
        "duplicate_tolerance": 0.001
      },
      "retry_attempted": true,
      "reason": "low_text_coverage",
      "full": {
        "reference_chars": 4832,
        "covered_chars": 4830,
        "duplicate_chars": 0,
        "coverage": 0.9995860927152318
      }
    },
    {
      "mode": "guarded",
      "selected": "detect",
      "detector": {
        "reference_chars": 5851,
        "covered_chars": 5845,
        "duplicate_chars": 0,
        "coverage": 0.9989745342676466
      },
      "guard": {
        "coverage": 0.95,
        "min_chars": 20,
        "min_gain": 0.005,
        "duplicate_tolerance": 0.001
      },
      "retry_attempted": false,
      "snapped_boxes": [
        3
      ]
    },
    {
      "mode": "guarded",
      "selected": "detect",
      "detector": {
        "reference_chars": 4491,
        "covered_chars": 4486,
        "duplicate_chars": 0,
        "coverage": 0.9988866622133156
      },
      "guard": {
        "coverage": 0.95,
        "min_chars": 20,
        "min_gain": 0.005,
        "duplicate_tolerance": 0.001
      },
      "retry_attempted": false
    }
  ]
}